How to choose a mortgage broker in Tampa: the 5 questions to ask
Published August 21, 2026 · By Adrian Colin, licensed mortgage broker in Florida and Texas, NMLS 1684240
I am going to write this the way I would if we were sitting in my office on Hoover Boulevard and you asked me what to look for — even if you end up working with someone else. An informed buyer is a better client for anyone.
First: broker, bank and direct lender are not the same thing
This confusion costs people money, so it is worth separating clearly.
A bank offers you the bank’s loans. One menu. If you do not fit their product, the conversation ends.
A direct lender lends its own money. Same limit: their catalog is the only catalog.
A wholesale broker does not lend its own money. It works with dozens of wholesale lenders and investors, and its job is to find which one fits your case.
The practical difference is this: when a bank tells you no, that only means that bank said no. It does not mean you do not qualify for a mortgage. Understanding that distinction changes a lot about what you believe about yourself.
When a bank is the better option
I will be fair, because we are not always the answer.
If you are a W2 employee with good credit, years of steady employment, and you are buying a conventionally priced home, your bank can give you a perfectly good loan. Sometimes with a relationship discount. In that profile the difference between options is small.
A broker becomes valuable when your file does not fit the standard box. And in Tampa, plenty of files do not.
When you need a broker
- You are self-employed and your tax returns show little after deductions
- You do not have a Social Security Number and want to buy with an ITIN
- You have a work permit and were told you no longer qualify after the 2025 FHA change
- You live abroad and want to invest in Florida
- Your income is not W2: commission, tips, rental income, contracts
- You have already been told no once or twice
If you recognize yourself in that list, a broker is not a luxury: it is the difference between buying and not buying.
The five questions you should ask
Keep this list. It works for evaluating us and for evaluating anyone.
1. What is your NMLS number?
Every mortgage loan originator in the United States has one, and it is public. Look it up on NMLS Consumer Access, which is free, and you will see their license, their states and their history. Any legitimate professional gives it to you without hesitating. If they stall, the interview is over.
2. How many lenders do you work with?
If the answer is one, they are not a broker. And ask whether any of them specializes in your specific situation.
3. Have you closed files like mine?
Be specific: self-employed, ITIN, work permit, foreign national. A broker with real experience will describe the whole process without being asked. One without it gives vague answers.
4. Will you give me the Loan Estimate in writing?
It is a standardized federal form with every cost on it. Never accept numbers over the phone. The document lets you compare offers side by side, because everyone uses the same format. It is your best tool and it is free.
5. What happens if my file is not approved?
The answer you want is not “it will definitely be approved.” It is a plan: what is missing, how long it takes to fix, what other route exists. Optimism without a plan is a red flag.
Warning signs
- They quote you a rate before looking at your credit. It is not possible to know it without reviewing the file.
- They offer you an FHA loan with an ITIN. FHA requires a Social Security Number. Ask for the product sheet in writing.
- They pressure you with artificial urgency. “Today only” does not exist in mortgages.
- They suggest leaving something off the application. That is mortgage fraud, and you are the one signing.
- They will not give you their NMLS or it does not appear in the registry.
- They charge you upfront to “lock” your rate or review your case.
How to read reviews
Five stars across eight reviews does not tell you much. What matters is volume and content.
Look for reviews that describe situations like yours. One that says “great service” is worth little; one that says “helped us with a complicated loan using income that was not W2” tells you exactly what to expect.
And look at how they respond to negative reviews, if there are any. That reveals more about a business’s character than the good ones do.
About us, so you can compare
Using the same criteria I just gave you:
- Licenses: Adrian Colin, NMLS #1684240. Infinity Wholesale Mortgages, LLC, Company NMLS #2420223. Licensed by the Florida Office of Financial Regulation and the Texas Department of Savings and Mortgage Lending (SML). Verify us on NMLS Consumer Access.
- Model: wholesale broker. We compare among multiple investors for every file.
- Reviews: read our Google reviews.
- Recognition: BusinessRate, Best of 2026, Town ’n’ Country.
- Office: 5404 Hoover Blvd, Suite 6, Tampa, FL 33634.
- Area: Tampa, St. Petersburg, Clearwater, Brandon, Town ’n’ Country and all of Florida and Texas.
- Languages: English and Spanish, the whole process.
What we specialize in: self-employed buyers who qualify with a profit and loss statement without needing a licensed CPA, ITIN mortgages, conventional loans for work permit holders, foreign national programs, flexible Non-QM, Florida Housing down payment assistance, and zero down options for those who qualify.
What to expect from a first call with us
Fifteen to twenty minutes. We ask about your income, your approximate credit, how much you have saved and what you are looking for. At the end we tell you one of three things: you qualify and this is the range, you qualify with these adjustments and this is the timeline, or not yet and this is the plan.
We do not ask for a credit card and there is no charge for the review. And if your own bank turns out to be the better deal, we will tell you.
Browse the programs in our Casa Catalog, add the ones you are interested in, and leave us your name, phone and email. We show up to the call already knowing what you are looking for.
Sources
- NMLS Consumer Access — public registry of mortgage loan originator licenses
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — Loan Estimate, standardized disclosure form
- HUD, Mortgagee Letter 2025-09 — Revisions to FHA residency requirements
- Florida Office of Financial Regulation — mortgage broker licensing
Keep reading
- How to buy a home in Florida with an ITIN in 2026: the honest guide
- Self-employed mortgages in Florida: how to qualify without tax returns
- Can I buy a home in Florida with an EAD in 2026? What changed with FHA
- See all the programs in the Casa Catalog
Adrian Colin is CEO/President and Loan Officer of Infinity Wholesale Mortgages, LLC, a mortgage broker licensed by the Florida Office of Financial Regulation and the Texas Department of Savings and Mortgage Lending (SML). NMLS #1684240. Company NMLS #2420223.
Informational and educational article. Not a loan commitment or an offer of credit. Programs and requirements change without notice. Subject to credit and property approval, income verification and appraisal. Equal Housing Opportunity.